Scenes from
Puglia, Puglia, Italy, Tasted on November 8-14, 2006 — Puglia
(pronounced Pooleeyah) is located on the
southeast coast of Italy - the heel of the boot as it were. I
got to spend a week there courtesy of some folks from Puglia as well
as Oldways. For me the week
ended up being a series of little vignettes and observations. I'll
share them (as well as
138
photos to document most of the details) here.
∞
First a word on the way these trips work. Every industry
has something like this. When it comes to regions promoting their local
products the region either directly (or through a partner in the target
country) invites industry influentials for a visit. In the food industry
influentials are typically chefs, nutritionists, food scientists,
distributors, buyers, retailers, and of course... press (which for
better or worse, bloggers are now considered). Typically in these
situations the host makes it clear that there is no quid pro quo
expected, and while they certainly have an agenda, ultimately they are
trying to expose the visitors to the wonders of their locale. What
opinion the visitor forms, and what they do with that opinion is
completely up to them. And everyone I know personally who writes based
on trips like these (or even just free samples in the mail) always
discloses that up front so there's no confusion. To me the question
isn't whether the writer has been influenced. Of course they have. The
question is whether the writer will be fair in their assessment. Now
that disclosure is complete, I'll make my best effort on the fair part.
∞
Some background on my history with olive oil. Growing
up, when my father cooked it was almost always Italian food from
one specific cookbook. And he cooked with olive oil. Lots of it.
Typically it was industrially produced olive oil, it said it was from
Italy (but who knows where the olives came from), and it came in a huge
square can with a spout. It had a slightly more interesting color than
typical olive oil, but I don't recall any significant flavor over other
standard cooking oils we used.
I lived in Israel for a year between high school and
college and then again during my second year of college. I think it was
really here that I first started to encounter olive oil outside of my
dad's Italian cooking. Israel is right on the Mediterranean and has a
healthy number of olive trees of its own. Olive oil is found everywhere,
dressing chopped vegetable salads, and floating like a jeweled pool atop
chummus spread out on a plate. One day while in college there I saw my
Israeli Arab friends deep frying their falafel in olive oil.
My relationship with olive oil is long and more diverse
than that of the typical American. That said, I still felt like a novice
when it came to distinguishing between different olive oils. In fact,
for the most part I felt that any olive oil that wasn't out of the
middle east (Lebanon, Syria, or Israel) was relatively flavorless. These
middle eastern oils were deeply flavorful. They actually tasted like,
well, olives. I know not every ingredient in a dish needs to be
individually distinguishable from the rest. But in any dish that I
wanted to add olive oil, I wanted to be able to taste some impact in the
final product.
It was finally a chef focused on Italian food that would
finish many of his dishes with high quality Italian olive oil that
showed me that the subtleties of the product were suited to dishes where
its flavor could hang out in the background, and its texture could take
center stage. I remembered back in high school in Boston, my favorite
steak sub shop finishing their subs with a squirt of olive oil. It all
came together for me. Armed with this only moderately dysfunctional
history I left for Puglia.
∞
The week was packed. Seriously, they ran us ragged. If I
was expecting a relaxing time on the coast, it was not to be.
Lectures (with simultaneous translation which made us feel like we
were in the U.N.), panels, meals, tastings, tours, and more tastings
filled each day from first thing in the morning to late at night. I had
my favorite moments, but the week not lacking for activity.
∞
I was surprised at how much the
landscape, architecture, and archaeology reminded me of the coast of
Israel. In retrospect it's not surprising as both geographies hug the
Mediterranean. But the similarities still were striking.
∞
We were lucky that we got to spend time exploring some
non-food attractions. While an artisanal prosciutto manufacturer giving
out copious free samples would have added to my personal enjoyment of
the
Castel del Monte, I suppose it was still
pretty cool even without some sort of ham related element.
∞
One thing I particularly enjoyed was getting to see
everyone in the production chain of the oil throughout the week. We met
growers,
pickers,
producers,
bottlers,
distributors, and importers. We even got to see a several hundred
year old underground production facility (not in use anymore). Despite
asking several hundred questions I have no idea how they got
the millstone down there. The pickers were also good to meet as like
just about every older Italian man we met on the trip they had an
incredibly
distinctive look - right out of central casting. One of our
traveling companions also noted that the little Italian boys dressed
like their grandfathers. Very cute.
∞
We stopped at one grower/producer who had purchased his
own fancy title. The
count (yes a count) had a pretty great spread including possibly the
most dramatic spot we visited in Puglia - an
underground wine cellar that
upon entry felt like you were
deep inside one of castles in Lord of the Rings. Super super cool.
∞
Moira Orfei posters haunted us everywhere we went in Bari. If my
daughter had been on the trip she would have screamed as we passed them
yelling "scary clown, scary clown". (Seriously, check out
her site.)
∞
The food on the trip was pretty much out of control.
Enormous meal after enormous meal treated us to what must have been
almost the entire range of Pugliese specialties. It is very hard to cook
well for 100 people at once. It is almost impossible to keep
consistently high quality when serving multiple meals over the course fo
a week for a group of 100 people. And sure enough some of the meals
suffered from the need to scale. But two in particular were exceptional.
The first was the opening dinner. The conference
gathered a series of accomplished chefs at our home base the
Corte Bracco de Germani (which
was gorgeous) who each did a course with three small items all based on
olive oil of course. The courses included olive oil with:
cheese,
fruit,
fish, meat,
greens,
legumes,
fried items,
pasta,
dessert, and of course
bread. I already am a fan of trying lots of things so the variety
was great. But so many of the small items we got were well done that I
really enjoyed the meal. If I had to choose one dish that stood out I
would have to mention the fermented ricotta. I'd never had it before and
it had an acidity and flavor that I found super enjoyable. I need to
figure out how to find it stateside. Of course if there's one moment I'd
rather forget it's
spilling my wine all over myself and my neighbor. Luckily the wine
came out of his jacket as well as my clothes. Maybe I was drunk from all
the olive oil.
The other meal that blew us away was held at
Masseria Barbera. We eventually
figured out that a masseria is a "term
used mainly in southern Italy, referring to a wine-producing farm or
estate". I really do my best to focus exclusively on the flavor of
the food to determine my impression of a meal. I work hard so that
service, decor, environment, menu, and other influences remain at a
minimum. And frankly, quantity of food almost never impacts my judgment,
but the fact is that the amount of food at this "lunch" was so
overwhelming that it couldn't help but be memorable. And to be clear,
it's the amount of good food they served that overwhelmed us. I pride
myself on documenting meals in detail but this simply wasn't possible
unless I'd brought a staff of 2 others with me (at least). Frankly, I'd
like to tell you about all the good dishes I had, but I know I couldn't
have tasted them all.
Honestly, by the end of this extravaganza I felt like I
knew what some of Henry the Eighth's meals were like. I had visions in
my head of hundreds of sheep being slaughtered somewhere in preparation
for day three of our orgiastic meal. That clearly would have led to
good, old-fashioned sheep roasting. That said, in reality it the meal
was only a few hours long (five?) but I started to get the sense of what
days of eating would have felt like. I'll admit I am eager to get back
there for a proper lunch.
Some highlights from our "spread" included:
huge
platters of
cheese,
pickled lampascioni,
gorgeous sliced beets,
cured
meats,
fresh mozarella, freshly made
orechietti made by
this adorable lady (who danced a jig for us later - no I'm not
kidding),
pickled onions,
eggplant,
zucchini,
quiche,
Romanesco cauliflower,
mounds (and
baskets)
of
fried
goodness,
savory sausages and
other cooked innards,
lamb chops, and
plate after
plate after
plate of
gorgeous
sweet
desserts. Oh... and of course,
adorable cannolis.
∞
There were other superlative food moments. In between
meals we would get various buffets and samplings prepared for us.
Visiting
olive oil grower and producer Giancarlo Ceci we were treated to a
tasting of their olive oil and wines. It was simple antipasti, and as
good as everything was, the
thick cut ham in particular stood out for me (among the other
meats,
cheeses,
olives, and
wine). It was a local prosciutto (not from Parma). Aside from being
beautifully cured with just the right amount of saltiness, it was cut
thick. I guess here in the U.S. the stuff is so expensive that we cut it
super thin to make it last. (Yes, I know it tastes good that way too.)
But there was so much chewy goodness in each bite with the thick slices
that it was a completely new (and delicious) experience.
We also had a great lunch at Ristorante il Melograno in
Trani on our last day. The olive oil we had there was among the best I
tried in Puglia and it came from
Masseria Protomastro. I
need to hunt it down.
Horse meat anyone? That's what
this sauce was for.
∞
I did taste olive oil on the trip. Even with my new
eagerness to expand my olive oil palate I had a hard time keeping things
straight. Mostly I got an overall impression of grass, lightness, and
fresh green tones. I admit that my palate is simply not developed enough
when it comes to olive oil to give really fine grain impressions. That
said, it was clear to me that some of the Pugliese olive oils we tasted
would be contenders at the very least to be one of my finishing oils of
choice.
∞
If I had one recommendation for future trips it would be
more formal tastings. To be fair, we had lots of olive oil in many
different circumstances each day. But it still was kind of haphazard.
And by my rough count we only tasted about 20 different olive oils over
the course of the week. Honestly I would have preferred to try about 50
different olive oils. I'd propose 10 a day in a more formal and
consistent setting each morning before we got going. We could take notes
and then decide which we liked the best. It also would have been nice to
know which oils were actually available in which countries other than
Italy. I know that some of the oils we tasted are not actually available
in the U.S.
∞
On trips of most kinds, being far away with a bunch of
strangers speeds up the process of getting to know each other. There was
certainly no shortage of interesting and friendly people to meet from
the group of folks that were present. That said, this trip was
particularly fun as I got to spend my time with a bunch of people I'd
only met on e-mail. Give Oldways credit for reaching out to the
so-called "new media". Josh from
The Food Section, Heidi
from 101 Cookbooks, and
Nicole and Oliver from Delicious
Days were all there. Rounding out our little coffee klatch were also
two freelancers Matt and Harris.
As much as I liked the trip, I found it way more enjoyable because I got
to spend it with these folks, no longer just e-mail addresses. I'm
pretty sure the Oldways folks found us to be slightly more "boisterous"
than their historical invitees, but hopefully that energy is considered
a good thing. :)
∞
Perhaps the most impactful aspect of the week for me was
the impression I got from the local folks who put on the event. When you
drive around Puglia (which we did extensively in our buses), there are
some grapes, figs, and all manner of food that grows, but the place is
lousy with
olive
groves. Everywhere you went there were olive trees. Some were
hundreds of years old with enormous thick gnarled trunks.
Whether it was the head of the local city council, the
organizer of the local olive council, (our friend) the local count that
grows his own olives and produces his own olive oil, or the myriad other
folks we met with, all these people are deeply connected with and (maybe
more importantly) deeply dependent on a single natural resource - the
olive. Granted we spent time with the olive folks, and there are clearly
other industries (fishing for example) in the area. But olives and olive
oil specifically permeated everything. Not just the food. These people
had placed their bet. All in. On one tree. Maybe if I'd grown up in an
agricultural community that specialized I wouldn't find this such an
interesting experience. But for me, betting the livelihood of your
region, your family, yourself, on a tree is pretty gutsy.
∞
And that's fundamentally the challenge for the local
olive economy. I spent as much time as I could on the trip tasting the
products of the region, I couldn't help but think about their situation
from a business perspective. Large corporations dominate the market for
olive oil. And while significant time was spent discussing growing that
market, I think it's likely that with a larger market, the lion's share
of the growth will accrue to the already big players. Ultimately that
leaves the Pugliese producers to focus on quality. The really have no
choice. And hopefully as the market grows, the number of people that
want a quality olive oil will grow as well.
But defining quality is difficult especially when the
rules for talking to customers vary widely. Anyone can bring in crappy
olives across the border into Italy and declare it "made in Italy". I
claim most consumers are already past their tolerance for details just
looking for olive oil that's Italian. Trying to determine what region
it's from, whether it's certified by the local D.O.P., what varietals
went into it, etc. are beyond the resources of most people. Just getting
them to look for "extra virgin" is probably the best one can hope for.
∞
I'm not sure it matters whether it's courage or
necessity driving this community to try and make a name for their
region. Likely it's both. And regardless of the impetus, I'm pretty
certain they will persevere until they do.
∞
P.S. More impressions from the trip at:
P.P.S. Give me some time to report on an olive oil
tasting back in Seattle. Consider it the follow-up to my trip to Puglia.